Astrophysicist at Indiana University who posted on the cryptography mailing list on January 17, 2009, raising concerns about government regulation and botnet exploitation of Bitcoin — among the earliest substantive criticisms of the system.
Jonathan Thornburg is an astrophysicist at Indiana University. He participated in the cryptography mailing list discussion about Bitcoin in January 2009, shortly after Satoshi Nakamoto released Bitcoin v0.1.
Mailing List Criticism: On January 17, 2009, Thornburg posted a detailed response to Satoshi’s email about Bitcoin’s potential uses. He raised two fundamental concerns that would echo through Bitcoin’s history:
First, government regulation: “In the modern world, no major government wants to allow untracable international financial transactions above some fairly modest size thresholds.” He cited the standard regulatory arguments — money laundering, tax evasion, and terrorism financing.
Second, botnet exploitation: “But if each machine in a million-node botnet sends 10 cents to a randomly chosen machine in another botnet on the other side of the world, you’ve just moved $100K, in a way that seems very hard to trace.” He concluded that “no major government is likely to allow Bitcoin in its present form to operate on a large scale.”
He also raised concerns about botnets burning through pay-per-send email filters and botnet operators profiting from Bitcoin mining.
Significance: Thornburg’s criticisms represented the mainstream security community’s initial skepticism toward Bitcoin. His concerns about government regulation proved prescient — governments worldwide have since imposed extensive cryptocurrency regulations. His botnet concerns also materialized, as cryptocurrency mining malware became widespread in subsequent years. Satoshi responded to his concerns directly on the mailing list.
1 entries
Indiana University astrophysicist Jonathan Thornburg raises concerns about government regulation and botnet exploitation of Bitcoin, arguing that no major government would allow untraceable international transfers and that botnets could move $100K by having a million nodes each send 10 cents.